Roofing Materials Comparison Guide

Asphalt shingles, metal, tile, slate, and TPO — compared by lifespan, cost per square, durability, and best use for Oklahoma homes and businesses. Plain-English facts to help you choose the right roof for your budget.

Since 2015 4.9★ · 127+ Reviews Owens Corning Preferred CIB #80004070 3-Year Workmanship Warranty $98/mo Financing

Roofing Materials at a Glance

Costs shown are installed price per roofing square — one square equals 100 square feet. Actual pricing depends on roof size, pitch, complexity, and current material costs.

Material Lifespan Cost / Square Durability Best For
3-Tab Asphalt Shingles 15–20 years $90–$160 Wind 60–70 mph; minimal hail protection Budget roofs, short-term ownership
Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles 25–30 years $120–$250 Wind 110–130 mph; good hail resistance Most Oklahoma homes — the standard choice
Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles 25–35 years $180–$350 UL 2218 Class 4; best hail protection in asphalt Hail-prone areas, insurance premium discounts
Standing Seam Metal 40–70 years $400–$800 Wind 120+ mph; Class A fire; dent-resistant Long-term owners, premium homes
Corrugated Metal 30–50 years $250–$450 Strong, but exposed fasteners can loosen over time Barns, sheds, budget-conscious metal buyers
Clay Tile 50–100 years $500–$900 Class A fire; excellent hail; heavy — needs reinforced structure Spanish & Mediterranean architecture
Concrete Tile 40–75 years $300–$700 Class A fire; good hail; heavy — needs reinforced structure Southwestern & tile-look homes
Slate 75–200 years $800–$1,500 Fireproof; extremely durable; requires reinforced deck Historic and luxury homes
TPO (Flat / Commercial) 15–25 years $350–$650 Heat-welded seams; reflective; good puncture resistance Commercial and low-slope flat roofs

Lifespan estimates assume proper installation, adequate ventilation, and routine maintenance. Oklahoma's hail and wind can shorten the life of any roofing material.

Asphalt Shingles

The most common residential roofing material in North America — and the most popular choice across the Tulsa metro.

Asphalt Shingles

Most Popular

Asphalt shingles are made from a fiberglass mat saturated with asphalt and coated with mineral granules. They come in three main grades, each with a different price point and level of protection.

3-Tab Shingles
Flat, single-layer strips with a uniform look. The most economical option — but only 15–20 years of life, low wind ratings, and minimal hail protection. Fine for budget roofs, sheds, and short-term ownership.
Architectural Shingles
Multi-layered, dimensional shingles with a richer look and 110–130 mph wind ratings. Last 25–30 years and cost only 15–20% more than 3-tab. The minimum standard Proof Construction recommends for Oklahoma homes.
Class 4 Impact-Resistant
Architectural-grade shingles rated UL 2218 Class 4 — tested against a 2-inch steel ball impact. Built for Oklahoma hail season and often eligible for insurance premium discounts. Cost roughly 10–25% more than standard architectural.

Pros

  • Lowest upfront cost of any mainstream roofing material
  • Wide range of colors and styles, including Class 4 hail-resistant options
  • Quick installation — most homes done in 1–2 days
  • Easy to repair and match in the future
  • Widely available and backed by major manufacturer warranties

Cons

  • Shorter lifespan than metal, tile, or slate (15–35 years)
  • Hail and wind damage are real risks in Oklahoma storms
  • Granule loss accelerates as the roof ages
  • Heavier than metal and can be damaged by foot traffic
  • More waste at end of life — removed and landfilled

Metal Roofing

Steel and aluminum panels that shrug off wind, hail, and fire — the longest-lasting option short of tile and slate.

Metal Roofing

Longest-Lasting Common Option

Metal roofing is made from steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc. It carries a Class A fire rating, handles Oklahoma wind and hail well, and is one of the most energy-efficient options with the right finish.

Standing Seam
Vertical panels joined by raised, mechanically seamed locks with concealed fasteners. The premium metal system: 40–70 year lifespan, no exposed screws, superior weather resistance, and a clean modern look.
Corrugated Metal
Ribbed sheets with exposed fasteners. More affordable than standing seam and still very durable — but screws can back out over time and need periodic tightening. A practical choice for outbuildings and budget metal roofs.
Metal Shingles / Panels
Metal formed to imitate shingles, shakes, or tile. Combines metal durability with a traditional profile. A middle-ground option for homeowners who want metal performance without the standing-seam look.

Pros

  • 40–70 year lifespan — two to three times asphalt
  • Class A fire rating and excellent wind resistance
  • Hail may dent but rarely causes leaks
  • Reflective finishes cut summer cooling costs
  • Low maintenance and fully recyclable at end of life

Cons

  • Roughly 2–3x the installed cost of architectural shingles
  • Loud in heavy rain without proper underlayment and insulation
  • Dents can occur from large hail on thinner gauges
  • Expansion and contraction noise if not installed correctly
  • Color and finish options require an experienced installer

Clay & Concrete Tile

Century-class roofing with timeless curb appeal — heavy, beautiful, and extremely fire- and hail-resistant.

Clay & Concrete Tile

Premium & Heavy

Tile roofing is made from fired clay or molded concrete, common on Spanish, Mediterranean, and Southwestern-style homes. Both are Class A fire rated and handle hail far better than most materials — but their weight demands a reinforced roof structure.

Clay Tile
Fired clay tiles with rich, natural color that never fades. Lifespan of 50–100 years and excellent hail resistance. The most expensive tile option — expect $500–$900 per square installed.
Concrete Tile
Molded concrete tiles that mimic clay or slate at a lower cost ($300–$700 per square). Lifespan of 40–75 years with good hail and fire performance. Heavier than clay, so structure is critical.

Pros

  • 50–100 year lifespan with proper installation
  • Class A fire rating — among the safest roofs available
  • Excellent hail resistance in Oklahoma storms
  • Distinctive, high-end curb appeal that holds resale value
  • Color is baked in — never needs repainting

Cons

  • Very heavy — many homes need structural reinforcement
  • High material and installation cost
  • Brittle under foot traffic — walking on it can crack tiles
  • Requires specialized installers with tile experience
  • Not every roof pitch or framing system can support it

Slate Roofing

The gold standard of roofing — natural stone that can outlast the house itself.

Slate Roofing

Ultimate Durability

Natural slate is quarried stone cut into roofing tiles. It is fireproof, virtually impervious to hail, and lasts 75–200 years — which is why it graces historic and luxury homes. The trade-offs are weight, cost, and a very short list of qualified installers.

Pros

  • 75–200 year lifespan — the longest of any roofing material
  • Fireproof and extremely hail-resistant
  • Natural stone appearance that never goes out of style
  • Nearly zero maintenance for decades
  • Adds significant value to historic and premium homes

Cons

  • Most expensive option — $800–$1,500+ per square installed
  • Extremely heavy; almost always requires structural reinforcement
  • Brittle — damaged by foot traffic and impacts during installation
  • Few contractors are truly experienced with slate
  • Repairs can be costly and hard to color-match

TPO & Flat Roofing

The standard for commercial and low-slope roofs — white, reflective, and heat-welded for strength.

TPO (Flat / Commercial)

Commercial Standard

TPO (thermoplastic polyolefin) is a single-ply membrane installed on flat and low-slope roofs, typically 45–80 mils thick. Its white surface reflects the sun, seams are heat-welded into one continuous sheet, and it stands up to Oklahoma's freeze-thaw cycles — making it the go-to choice for Tulsa-area commercial buildings.

Pros

  • Reflective white surface cuts cooling costs on commercial buildings
  • Heat-welded seams are stronger than adhesive-bonded membranes
  • Handles Oklahoma's extreme temperature swings well
  • Lightweight and easy to maintain and repair
  • Good puncture and chemical resistance

Cons

  • 15–25 year lifespan — shorter than steep-slope materials
  • Requires a professional, experienced membrane installer
  • Seams are only as good as the welder who made them
  • Limited to low-slope and flat applications
  • Foot traffic and rooftop equipment require care and protection

Roofing Materials FAQ

Straight answers to the questions Oklahoma homeowners ask us most.

Which roofing material lasts longest?
Natural slate lasts the longest at 75 to 200+ years with proper installation and maintenance. Standing seam metal follows at 40–70 years, then clay and concrete tile at 40–100 years. Asphalt shingles, the most common residential option, last 15–35 years depending on grade.
Is metal roofing worth the cost in Oklahoma?
For homeowners planning to stay 20+ years, yes. Standing seam metal costs roughly 2–3x more than architectural shingles but lasts 40–70 years, handles Oklahoma hail and wind better, and carries a Class A fire rating. The higher upfront cost is offset by lifespan and lower maintenance over time.
Are class 4 shingles worth it after hail?
In Oklahoma — one of the most hail-prone states in the country — Class 4 impact-resistant shingles are generally worth the upgrade. They are rated under UL 2218 to withstand a 2-inch steel ball impact and typically cost only 10–25% more than standard architectural shingles while offering dramatically better hail protection.
How long do architectural shingles last in Oklahoma?
Architectural (dimensional) asphalt shingles typically last 25–30 years in Oklahoma's climate — 10+ years longer than 3-tab shingles. They carry wind ratings of 110–130 mph and are the minimum standard Proof Construction recommends for Tulsa metro homes.
What is the cheapest roofing material?
3-tab asphalt shingles are the least expensive option at roughly $90–$160 per square installed. However, they last only 15–20 years and offer minimal hail protection. Architectural shingles cost only 15–20% more but last a decade longer — making them the better value for most Oklahoma homeowners.
Is TPO roofing good for flat commercial roofs?
Yes. TPO (thermoplastic polyolefin) is the most popular single-ply membrane for flat commercial roofs in the Tulsa area. Its white reflective surface reduces cooling costs, seams are heat-welded for strength, and it handles Oklahoma's temperature swings well — typically lasting 15–25 years with proper maintenance.
Can I finance a new roof with bad credit?
Yes. Proof Construction offers $98/mo financing with approved credit — including scores as low as 550 — so a new roof doesn't have to wait. Call (918) 734-4444 for details and to see which plan fits your budget.

Not Sure Which Roof Is Right for Your Home?

Since 2015, Proof Construction has helped Tulsa metro homeowners compare materials honestly — no jargon, no pressure. Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, CIB #80004070, rated 4.9★ from 127+ reviews, and backed by a 3-year workmanship warranty. Financing available at $98/mo with approved credit as low as 550.

Get A Free Estimate (918) 734-4444

Need a Roofing Expert Who Speaks Your Language?

Free forensic inspections. Honest assessments. No jargon without explanation. Call Proof Construction today.

Get Your Free Inspection
Home Residential Roofing Commercial Roofing Storm Damage Emergency FAQ Hub Contact (918) 734-4444
Call Now