Home
Residential Roofing Commercial Roofing Storm Damage Repair Emergency Roofing Roof Replacement Roof Repair
Project Engineer Portal Contact (918) 734-4444
Insurance supplement intelligence Tulsa

Supplement Intelligence — Every Dollar Your Claim Deserves

Insurance adjusters miss an average of $4,200-$8,500 per claim. Our forensic audit finds every missing line item — code upgrades, underlayment, drip edge, ice & water shield. Free. No obligation.

Get Your Free Supplement Audit

Your Adjuster's Scope Is a Starting Point — Not the Final Word

Here's how it works: a storm hits Tulsa. You file a claim. An adjuster visits — typically spending 20-45 minutes inspecting your roof, mostly from the ground with binoculars. Compare that to what our insurance roof claim inspector documents in a full forensic claim inspection. They write an estimate using Xactimate software that auto-populates minimums. That estimate goes to your insurance carrier. You get a check.

What you don't see: the adjuster's software defaulted to the cheapest underlayment. It skipped ice and water shield because the software's regional defaults don't account for Oklahoma's freeze-thaw code requirements. It omitted drip edge because the adjuster couldn't see it from the ground. It used 3-tab shingle pricing for your architectural shingles.

This isn't fraud. It's systemic. Adjusters work for the carrier, whose job is protecting the carrier's financial interest. Our job is protecting yours.


The 12 Most Commonly Missed Line Items

Based on 100+ claim audits in the Tulsa metro, these are the items adjusters miss most frequently — and what each one costs when omitted:

Missing Item Why It's Missed Avg. Value Miss Rate
Ice & Water ShieldXactimate defaults don't account for OK freeze-thaw code$800-$2,40078%
Drip Edge (eaves + rakes)Invisible from ground; software doesn't auto-add$400-$1,20071%
Starter Strip ShinglesAdjusters assume it's 'included' — it's a separate line item$300-$80065%
Synthetic UnderlaymentSoftware defaults to #15 felt (half the cost, half the performance)$400-$1,00062%
Ridge VentOften counted at standard rate vs. actual linear feet$200-$60058%
Plumbing Pipe BootsAdjusters often miss or undercount penetrations$150-$50055%
Chimney Flashing/SaddleInvisible from ground unless adjuster climbs roof$400-$1,50052%
Valley Metal/FlashingScoped as W-valley instead of closed-cut or metal$300-$90048%
Decking ReplacementNot visible until tear-off; adjuster can't estimate$0-$2,50044%
Waste Factor (15%+ for cuts)Software defaults to 10% — not enough for complex roofs$200-$70041%
Permit FeesAdjusters 'forget' to include municipal permit costs$150-$40038%
Code Upgrade (IBC 2024)Oklahoma adopted IBC 2024 — older scopes miss new requirements$500-$2,00035%

How Our Supplement Intelligence System Works

1. Upload Your Scope

Send us your adjuster's estimate (PDF or Xactimate file). We accept any format — just forward what your carrier sent you. Takes 60 seconds.

2. Line-by-Line Forensic Audit

We compare every single line item against our forensic documentation (drone photos, moisture maps, impact analysis), manufacturer installation specifications, and Oklahoma building code. We find what the adjuster missed.

3. Formal Supplement Submission

We prepare a formal supplement package with photographic evidence, manufacturer spec sheets, and applicable code citations. This goes directly to your insurance carrier's supplement department — not back to the original adjuster.

4. Approval & Full Payment

With proper documentation, over 90% of our supplements are approved on the first submission. The carrier issues a supplemental check — typically within 7-14 business days. This check is yours. It pays for the items the adjuster missed.

Don't Let Your Adjuster Decide What Your Roof Is Worth

Free supplement audit. 90%+ approval rate. Average supplement adds $4,200-$8,500.

Get Your Free Audit

Or call (918) 734-4444. Upload your scope and we'll have results within 48 hours. Get a free roof estimate from Proof Construction. Explore all roofing solutions from Proof Construction. Try the roof cost estimator for a ballpark figure.

Proudly Serving the Greater Tulsa Metro

Tulsa Broken Arrow Bixby Jenks Owasso Sand Springs Claremore Sapulpa Glenpool

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an insurance supplement for a roof claim?

A supplement is an additional payment from your insurance company when the initial adjuster's estimate misses items required for a code-compliant roof replacement. Common missing items include: ice and water shield, drip edge, starter strips, synthetic underlayment, ridge vent, plumbing boots, flashing, and code-required upgrades. Proof Construction's Supplement Intelligence system audited over 800 claims and found the average adjuster misses $4,200-$8,500 in legitimate line items.

Why do insurance adjusters miss items on roof estimates?

Adjusters typically inspect from the ground using binoculars — they can't see wind-lift creasing, granular adhesion failure, or compromised flashing seals. Their estimating software (Xactimate) auto-populates minimums that don't reflect actual Oklahoma building code requirements. They work for the insurance carrier, whose financial incentive is to minimize payout. This isn't malice — it's systemic. Our supplement audit bridges the gap between what the adjuster wrote and what your roof actually needs.

How much more money does a supplement typically add to my claim?

Based on 100+ claims audited in the Tulsa metro, the average supplement adds $4,200-$8,500 to the initial claim payout. The range varies by roof size and what was missed — a 30-square roof missing ice and water shield, drip edge, and starter strips might see a $6,000 supplement, while a smaller roof missing only a few items might see $1,500-$3,000. Supplements are paid directly from your insurance carrier — they cost you nothing.

Do I have to pay for the supplement audit?

No. Proof Construction's supplement audit is completely free. We're paid when the supplement is approved and we complete the work — same as any roofing contractor. There's zero out-of-pocket cost to you. The audit is valuable to us because it ensures your roof is installed correctly with all required components, which protects our workmanship warranty.

How long does the supplement process take?

The supplement audit itself takes 24-48 hours after we receive your adjuster's scope of work. We compare it line-by-line against our forensic documentation, manufacturer specs, and Oklahoma building code. Once submitted, insurance carriers typically respond within 7-14 business days. Most supplements are approved on the first submission when properly documented — our approval rate is over 90%.

Can I file a supplement after my roof is already replaced?

Yes — but it's harder. Supplements can be filed up to 2 years after the claim settlement in Oklahoma, but you lose significant leverage once the roof is done. The ideal time is BEFORE installation, when the carrier knows the work hasn't been completed and a supplement is required to finish properly. If your roof was already replaced by another contractor and items were missed, contact us — we may still be able to help.