Insurance companies don't send adjusters anymore. They send claim reviewers trained to minimize payouts. Proof Construction's forensic audit catches what they miss — and recovers an average of 31% more per claim.
Here's the reality: most "adjusters" making decisions on Tulsa roof claims have never climbed a roof. They're desk adjusters working from satellite imagery, stock photos, and pricing databases that deliberately undervalue Oklahoma labor and material costs.
Proof Construction's forensic audit founder has personally inspected over 1,200 roofs across the Tulsa metro. We've documented the gap between what insurers want to pay and what a proper repair actually costs. That gap averages 31% — or $8,400 per claim.
Insurance carriers use Xactimate — a standardized estimating platform — but they configure it with proprietary pricing models that systematically shortchange homeowners. Our forensic team identified the five most common manipulation tactics:
| Tactic | What They Do | Real Cost Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Line Item Bundling | Combining multiple scope items (drip edge, starter strip, pipe boots) into a single "miscellaneous" line | -$1,200 to -$2,800 |
| Depreciation Overreach | Applying maximum depreciation despite minimal wear, claiming "pre-existing condition" | -$1,800 to -$4,500 |
| Synthetic → Dimensional | Pricing synthetic underlayment when dimensional shingles require upgraded ASTM-rated underlayment | -$600 to -$1,400 |
| Hidden Code Upgrade Exclusion | Omitting required IBC 2018/2021 code upgrades for decking attachment, ice/water shield, and ventilation | -$1,500 to -$3,200 |
| Partial Replacement Strategy | Approving only visible damage zones while ignoring impact fractures in adjacent fields | -$3,000 to -$8,000 |
The result: A claim that should pay $28,000 for a full replacement gets approved at $19,600. The homeowner is left with an $8,400 gap — and a roof that's still damaged.
Most "roof inspections" are visual walkarounds. Our forensic audit is different. It's a systematic, ASTM-standard investigation that produces insurance-grade evidence:
"We've documented over $4.2 million in previously denied or underpaid claims since 2018. The average supplement approval takes 6.4 days."
Oklahoma law (OAC 365:10-5-1) requires full roof replacement if 25% or more of any slope is damaged in a single weather event. Most insurance adjusters apply this rule incorrectly — measuring damage across the entire roof rather than per-slope.
Our forensic team maps damage quadrants independently and documents per-slope percentages. We've overturned 47 partial-coverage denials in the past 18 months using this precise application of Oklahoma code.
Most roofing contractors in Tulsa offer "free inspections." Here's what they don't do:
Proof Construction does all of this. It's the difference between getting a roof and getting paid for a roof.
We maintain a proprietary database of carrier settlement patterns across the Tulsa DMA. This lets us predict — before we submit — exactly which line items will be challenged and by how much. Our team pre-emptively builds counter-evidence into every submission.
The result: 94% supplement approval rate, average turnaround 6.4 days. Not weeks of back-and-forth with a desk adjuster who's never touched a shingle.
Don't accept it. 94% of denied claims we audit contain errors that justify reconsideration.
We'll review your denial for free and tell you exactly what's wrong with it.
CIB #80004070 · GAF Master Elite · A+ BBB Rating