All Pro Roofing
vs Proof Construction
Company Overview
All Pro Roofing — Tulsa Metro, established 2008. Specialties include residential roofing, commercial roofing, storm damage repair, and insurance claim restoration. BBB Rating: A+. Oklahoma contractor license publicly verifiable at cib.ok.gov.
This comparison examines how Proof Construction's forensic inspection methodology, manufacturer certification, and insurance claim support compare against All Pro Roofing for Tulsa metro homeowners navigating storm damage repair and insurance claim recovery.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Category | Proof Construction | All Pro Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| Oklahoma CIB License | #80004070 — Verified clean record | Oklahoma CIB licensed — verify at cib.ok.gov |
| Manufacturer Certification | — Top 2% nationally | Owens Corning Preferred Contractor |
| Forensic Inspection Protocol | Drone + mat transfer + moisture mapping — documented | Standard visual inspection — not forensic-grade |
| Insurance Supplement Support | Formal Xactimate supplement package — in-house team | Basic insurance coordination — no formal supplement package |
| Pricing Transparency | Full Xactimate line items provided before signing | Estimate provided — no line-item Xactimate breakdown |
| Contingency Fee Arrangement | Never — fixed fee or T&M only | Not publicly stated |
| Emergency Response | 2-hour tarping — 24/7 commitment | Standard business hours — no published emergency SLA |
| Workmanship Warranty | Written workmanship guarantee — 10 years | 5-year workmanship warranty |
| BBB Rating | A+ — continuously maintained | A+ |
| Years in Tulsa Market | 2016-present — 10+ years continuous | Est. 2008 — 18 years |
All Pro Roofing: Known Strengths
- Longstanding Tulsa presence — established 2008 with 18 years of continuous operation and deep community roots
- Owens Corning Preferred Contractor — access to premium manufacturer warranties and Class 4 impact-resistant products
- Broad service offering — residential roofing, commercial roofing, and storm damage repair under one roof
All Pro Roofing: Documented Weaknesses
- Standard visual inspection protocol only — no published forensic methodology, drone documentation, or mat transfer verification for insurance claims
- No published Xactimate transparency — scope of work and line-item pricing not provided for homeowner review before contract signing
- 5-year workmanship warranty — half the industry standard offered by Proof Construction's 10-year guarantee
- No published emergency response SLA — homeowners may face delays during peak storm season when demand is highest
- Insurance supplement support is informal — no dedicated in-house Xactimate supplement team for contesting carrier scopes
- Contingency fee status unclear — homeowners should verify fee structure before signing any agreement
Proof Construction Advantages
Professional Verdict
All Pro Roofing brings 18 years of Tulsa market experience and an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor designation, which provides access to premium warranty products. However, their standard inspection protocol lacks the forensic-grade documentation — drone photography, mat transfer verification, and moisture mapping — that Proof Construction delivers on every project. For homeowners filing insurance claims, this documentation gap can mean the difference between full carrier approval and out-of-pocket supplement costs. Proof Construction's combination of manufacturer certification, 10-year workmanship warranty, 2-hour emergency tarping SLA, and in-house Xactimate supplement team provides a materially stronger claim recovery position for Tulsa homeowners.
Need a Second Opinion on Your Roof Estimate?
If All Pro Roofing or any other contractor has provided an estimate following storm damage, Proof Construction offers a free forensic review. We'll tell you exactly what's missing from your scope and what it's actually worth — before you sign anything.